| 8/26 | A | Cleveland Heights (OH) (11-2) | [I:1] | W | 43-41 | |
| 9/1 | H | Hudson Catholic (MA) (0-1) | W | 55-0 | ||
| 9/8 | H | Pope John XXIII (1-0) | L | 40-47 | ||
| 9/16 | A | Chaminade (NY) (0-1) | W | 40-19 | ||
| 9/22 | A | DePaul Catholic (1-0) | L | 12-28 | ||
| 9/30 | A | Delbarton School (1-0) | L | 0-45 | ||
| 10/6 | H | Seton Hall Prep (1-0) | L | 27-40 | ||
| 10/13 | H | St Peter's Prep (1-0) | L | 27-28 | ||
| 10/20 | A | Don Bosco Prep (1-0) | L | 14-35 | ||
| 10/27 | H | Bergen Catholic (1-0) | L* | 13-42 | ||
| * - game does not count in OHSAA rankings | ||||||