| 8/24 | H | Gahanna Lincoln (5-6) | [1:2] | W | 31-0 |  | 
| 8/31 | A | Indianapolis Cathedral (IN)  (5-5) | [2:0] | W | 39-34 |  | 
| 9/7 | H | Football North (via Clarkson SS) (ON)  (6-6) | [2:0] | W | 21-13 |  | 
| 9/15 | H | St Edward (11-3) | [1:1] | L | 30-36 |  | 
| 9/22 | A | St Ignatius (8-3) | [1:1] | L | 7-17 |  | 
| 9/28 | H | St Xavier (5-6) | [1:4] | W | 51-26 |  | 
| 10/5 | N | Archbishop Moeller (6-5) | [1:4] | L | 21-24 |  | 
| 10/12 | H | Winton Woods (12-2) | [2:8] | L | 10-28 |  | 
| 10/19 | H | Vianney (MO)  (6-3) | [2:0] | W | 48-7 |  | 
| 10/26 | H | La Salle (4-5) | [2:8] | W | 13-10 |  | 
| 11/2 | H | # Archbishop Moeller (6-5) | [1:4] | W | 35-0 |  | 
| 11/9 | N | # Lakota East (8-4) | [1:4] | W | 34-6 |  | 
| 11/16 | N | # Colerain (14-1) | [1:4] | L | 0-42 |  |