| 9/5 | A | Williamsville South (0-1) | W | 40-20 | ||
| 9/12 | A | Holy Trinity (0-1) | W | 49-19 | ||
| 9/18 | A | Walsh Jesuit (OH) (3-7) | [2:3] | L | 21-42 | |
| 9/26 | A | Aquinas Institute (1-0) | L | 7-48 | ||
| 10/2 | H | Canisius (4-0) | L | 34-64 | ||
| 10/10 | H | Saint Mary's (4-5) | [6:0] | W | 42-41 | |
| 10/16 | A | Cathedral Prep (PA) (2-0) | [2:0] | L | 14-34 | |
| 10/23 | A | St Joseph's Collegiate (1-3) | W | 42-20 | ||
| 10/30 | A | Bishop Timon (3-2) | W | 41-12 |