| 9/2 | A | Walsh Jesuit (OH) (9-3) | [II:5] | L | 6-48 | |
| 9/9 | A | Aquinas Institute (0-1) | W | 14-13 | ||
| 9/17 | H | WNY Maritime / Health Sciences (co-op) (1-1) | W | 43-30 | ||
| 9/24 | A | St Joseph's Collegiate (6-2) | W | 39-22 | ||
| 9/30 | A | Lancaster (2-0) | L | 20-24 | ||
| 10/7 | A | Massillon Washington (OH) (12-2) | [II:7] | L | 7-42 | |
| 10/15 | H | Erie (PA) (1-9) | [I] | W | 29-13 | |
| 10/22 | H | St Francis (5-3) | [III] | L | 13-36 | |
| 10/28 | A | Cathedral Prep (PA) (8-2) | [III] | L* | 6-40 | |
| * - game does not count in OHSAA rankings | ||||||