| 9/7 | A | St James (MD) (0-2) | W | 56-42 | ||
| 9/14 | H | Western Reserve Academy (OH) (6-3) | [7:0] | W | 27-10 | |
| 9/21 | A | Mount St Joseph (MD) (1-0) | L | 7-53 | ||
| 9/28 | H | Reigning Sports Academy (club) (OH) (1-2) | C* | cancelled | ||
| 10/3 | H | Youthbuild / Bishop Sycamore (OH) (4-5) | L* | 14-22 | ||
| 10/12 | H | Wyoming Seminary (1-2) | W | 28-0 | ||
| 10/19 | H | Linsly (WV) (7-3) | [6:0] | W | 28-26 | |
| 10/26 | A | The Hill School (0-1) | W | 17-6 | ||
| 11/2 | A | Academy of the New Church (0-1) | W | 49-28 | ||
| * - game does not count in OHSAA rankings | ||||||