| 9/4 | A | Martins Ferry (OH) (5-5) | [5:17] | W | 33-19 | |
| 9/11 | A | Kiski Prep (PA) (5-2) | [6:0] | L | 38-43 | |
| 9/18 | A | Mogadore (OH) (13-2) | [7:23] | L | 7-33 | |
| 9/26 | H | Trinity (OH) (4-6) | [6:19] | W | 33-15 | |
| 10/2 | A | Wheeling Central Catholic (9-1) | [6:0] | L | 14-36 | |
| 10/9 | A | Western Reserve Academy (OH) (5-3) | [5:0] | W | 47-35 | |
| 10/17 | H | Bishop Ready (OH) (6-4) | [6:21] | L | 14-31 | |
| 10/24 | H | Columbus Crusaders (club) (OH) (4-6) | W* | 35-14 | ||
| 10/30 | A | Columbus St Francis DeSales (OH) (10-2) | [3:9] | L | 12-41 | |
| 11/7 | H | Magnolia (10-0) | [5:0] | L* | 14-34 | |
| * - game does not count in OHSAA rankings | ||||||